Skip to main content
Home

Information for:

  • Alumni
  • Applicants
  • Current Students
  • Staff
  • Parents
  • Job Vacancies
  • Covid-19
  • Cymraeg
My country:

Main Menu

    • Clearing 2025
      • Clearing Courses
      • Apply Online
      • Call our Clearing Helpline
      • Clearing Live Chat
      • Offer Holder Hub
      • Book Clearing Open Day
    • Accommodation
      • Accommodation Guarantee
      • Find Your Perfect Room
    • About us
      • Virtual Tour
      • Why study in North Wales
      • Our Location
      • Student Clubs and Societies
      • Student Life
      • Reasons to study locally

    Clearing Open Days

    • Undergraduate
      • A–Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • Clearing 2025
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Offer Holders' Hub
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarship and Bursaries
      • Widening Access
      • Study in Welsh
      • Part-Time Study
      • Degree Apprenticeships
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Work Experience
      • Student Accommodation
      • Pocket Prospectus
      • Academic Calendar
    • Postgraduate Taught
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarships and Bursaries
      • Executive Education
      • January Start
      • Part-Time Study
      • Short Courses and CPD
      • A-Z of Short Courses and CPD
    • Postgraduate Research
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Funding
      • The Doctoral School

    Find a Course

    Clearing 2025

    Offer Holders' Hub

    Order a Pocket Prospectus

    Open Days

    Virtual Tour

    • Student Life
      • Student Life Home
      • Bangor and the Area
      • Social Life and Entertainment
      • Student Accommodation
      • Clubs and Societies
      • Sport
      • Virtual Tour
      • Videos and Vlogs
    • Your Experience at Bangor
      • Welcome 2024
      • Student Support
      • Skills and Employability
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Fees and Finances
      • Student Ambassadors

    Student Profiles

    Student Videos and Vlogs

    Welcome Week

    Virtual Tour

    • Choose Bangor
      • International Home
      • Why Bangor?
      • Location
      • Accommodation
      • Student Support
      • Contact Us
      • Bangor University's China website
    • Apply
      • Entry Requirements
      • Tuition Fees and Scholarships
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Study Abroad (Incoming)
      • Exchanges (Incoming)
      • Worldwide Partners

    Clearing 2025

    Country Specific Information

    Bangor University International College

    Find a Course

    • Research
      • Research Home
      • About Our Research
      • Research in our Academic Schools
      • Research Institutes and Centres
      • Research Portal
      • Integrated Research and Impact Support (IRIS) Service
      • Energy
      • REF 2021
      • Research News
    • Postgraduate Research Opportunities
      • Postgraduate Research
      • Doctoral School
    • Events and Training Opportunities
      • Researcher Development

    Royal Recognition: 2023 Queen's Anniversary Prize

    Bangor Research In Top 30 For Societal Impact In UK

    • The University
      • About Us
      • Our Mission
      • Strategy 2030
      • Annual Report & Financial Statements
      • Our Location
      • Academic Schools and Colleges
      • Services and Facilities
      • Vice-Chancellor's Office
      • Working with Business
      • Working with the Community
      • Sustainability
      • Health and Wellbeing
      • Contact Us
    • Working for Us
      • Job Vacancies
    • University Management and Governance
      • Policies and Procedures
      • Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement
      • Management and Governance
    • University and the Community
      • Pontio
      • Sports Facilities
      • Conference Facilities
      • Places to Eat and Drink
      • Public Events
      • Widening Access
      • Services to Schools
    • Business Services
      • Business Services Home
    • Collaboration Hub
      • Collaboration Hub
    • Conferencing and Business Dining
      • Conferencing Facilities
      • Business Dining
    • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
      • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
    • News
      • Current News
      • Research News
      • Student News
    • Events
      • Events
    • Announcements
      • Flag Announcements

    140th Anniversary

    Public Lectures

    • Clearing 2025
      • Clearing Courses
      • Apply Online
      • Book Clearing Open Day
      • Call our Clearing Helpline
      • Clearing Live Chat
      • Offer Holder Hub
    • Accommodation
      • Accommodation Guarantee
      • Find Your Perfect Room
    • About us
      • Virtual Tour
      • Why study in North Wales
      • Our Location
      • Student Clubs and Societies
      • Student Life
      • Reasons to study locally

    Clearing Open Days

    • Undergraduate
      • A–Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • Clearing 2025
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Offer Holders' Hub
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarship and Bursaries
      • Widening Access
      • Study in Welsh
      • Part-Time Study
      • Degree Apprenticeships
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Work Experience
      • Student Accommodation
      • Pocket Prospectus
      • Academic Calendar
    • Postgraduate Taught
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarships and Bursaries
      • Executive Education
      • January Start
      • Part-Time Study
      • Short Courses and CPD
      • A-Z of Short Courses and CPD
    • Postgraduate Research
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Funding
      • The Doctoral School

    Find a Course

    Clearing 2025

    Offer Holders' Hub

    Order a Pocket Prospectus

    Open Days

    Virtual Tour

    • Student Life
      • Student Life Home
      • Bangor and the Area
      • Social Life and Entertainment
      • Student Accommodation
      • Clubs and Societies
      • Sport
      • Virtual Student Experience
      • Videos and Vlogs
    • Your Experience at Bangor
      • Welcome 2024
      • Student Support
      • Skills and Employability
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Fees and Finances
      • Student Ambassadors

    Student Profiles

    Student Videos and Vlogs

    Welcome Week

    Virtual Tour

    • Choose Bangor
      • International Home
      • Why Bangor?
      • Location
      • Accommodation
      • Student Support
      • Contact Us
      • Bangor University's China website
    • Apply
      • Entry Requirements
      • Tuition Fees and Scholarships
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Study Abroad (Incoming)
      • Exchanges (Incoming)
      • Worldwide Partners

    Clearing 2025

    Country Specific Information

    Bangor University International College

    Find a Course

    • Research
      • Research Home
      • About Our Research
      • Research in our Academic Schools
      • Research Institutes and Centres
      • Research Portal
      • Integrated Research and Impact Support (IRIS) Service
      • Energy
      • REF 2021
      • Research News
    • Postgraduate Research Opportunities
      • Postgraduate Research
      • Doctoral School
    • Events and Training Opportunities
      • Researcher Development

    Royal Recognition: 2023 Queen's Anniversary Prize

    Bangor Research In Top 30 For Societal Impact In UK

    • The University
      • About Us
      • Our Mission
      • Strategy 2030
      • Annual Report & Financial Statements
      • Our Location
      • Academic Schools and Colleges
      • Services and Facilities
      • Vice-Chancellor's Office
      • Working with Business
      • Working with the Community
      • Sustainability
      • Health and Wellbeing
      • Contact Us
    • Working for Us
      • Job Vacancies
    • University Management and Governance
      • Policies and Procedures
      • Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement
      • Management and Governance
    • University and the Community
      • Pontio
      • Sports Facilities
      • Conference Facilities
      • Places to Eat and Drink
      • Public Events
      • Widening Access
      • Services to Schools
    • Business Services
      • Business Services Home
    • Collaboration Hub
      • Collaboration Hub
    • Conferencing and Business Dining
      • Conferencing Facilities
      • Business Dining
    • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
      • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
    • News
      • Current News
      • Research News
      • Student News
    • Events
      • Events
    • Announcements
      • Flag Announcements

    140th Anniversary

    Public Lectures

Information for:

  • Alumni
  • Applicants
  • Current Students
  • Staff
  • Parents
  • Job Vacancies
  • Covid-19
My country:

Search

Close

Breadcrumb

  • Cymraeg

Share this page:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Independence Day: what alien invasions tell us about current global politics

This article by Gregory Frame, Lecturer in Film Studies, Bangor University was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

When Soviet communism disintegrated, political scientist Francis Fukuyama famously declared that it was “the end of history”. He argued that Western liberal democracy and capitalism had triumphed as the world’s only viable system, and though humanity would still face bumps in the road, the ultimate progression to this eventuality for all nations would prove inevitable, even if it took many years.

The United States emerged from the aftermath of the Cold War as the world’s only remaining superpower. It was, as political commentator Charles Krauthammer declared, “the unipolar moment”. Former president Richard Nixon urged the United States to seize upon this opportunity to export American capitalism and democracy to the rest of the world.

While in reality the United States approached the new world order cautiously, one film that reflected the bombast and optimism of the “unipolar moment”, and captured the imagination of audiences (it was the highest-grossing film of 1996) was Independence Day (1996).

The story is a simple one. In the run-up to America’s July 4 weekend, the world is invaded by intergalactic space aliens bent on the destruction of the human race. Most of the world’s major cities are obliterated in the initial attack. Then the survivors, led by the US president and ex-Gulf War fighter pilot Thomas Whitmore (Bill Pullman), regroup, retaliate, and ultimately defeat the invaders, declaring the July 4 an international holiday. In a global war against a fearsome, inhuman “other”, American values become universal values.

In keeping with the politics of disaster movies, the nation before the attack is characterised by division, weakness and a decline in traditional values, with indecisive leaders and broken families. The cataclysm then brings about the restoration and renewal of conventional military strength and patriarchal dominance. Reunited in the desert following the destruction of the alien mothership, the African American fighter pilot Steven Hiller (Will Smith) and the Jewish scientist David Levinson (Jeff Goldblum), who masterminded the plan, embrace each other and their wives, led by the president of the United States. It is a triumphant, multicultural, resolutely patriarchal vision of a nation confident in its ability to take on all-comers.

Resurgence

Released last week, Independence Day: Resurgence tells essentially the same story. It strains to reheat some of the original’s major action set-pieces, particularly the destruction of the world’s major cities, notably London among them.

But this second film has to respond to a different geopolitical context – and it struggles to present the United States as one voice among many, a diluted system of global governance with America nominally at the helm. What is interesting about the opening few scenes before the aliens return, is its idealised vision of Fukuyama’s key idea: global liberal democracy has brought world peace.

But when that peace is disturbed, it is shown to be incapable of responding coherently to the impending threat. Former president Thomas Whitmore, again played by Bill Pullman, is asked once again to ride into battle to take the fight to the alien invaders. Again, the scientist Levinson formulates the plan to defeat them. Watching these (relatively) old men do their bit for humanity’s resistance the second time around tries to be rousing, but it is desperately unconvincing. Along with the film’s overreliance on CGI, its attempt to stimulate a semblance of patriotic fervour feels, looks, and sounds utterly fake.

Why? Perhaps because this post-9/11 United States is still hobbling its way out of the recession of 2008 and is facing the very real possibility of electing Donald Trump, a populist reality TV star looking to pull up the drawbridge and retreat from America’s role on the world stage. In such a context a message of cooperation and togetherness seems entirely out of step with the way the world looks now.

The possibility of global stability in the aftermath of the Cold War has evaporated on the battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan, with the rise of Islamic State, the war in Syria and the division caused by the migrant crisis in Europe. Climate change is happening.

The world is simply a much scarier and more uncertain place than it was in 1996, and it seems ever less likely that the United States has the will or the capacity to act as a global leader as it might have done 20 years ago. Independence Day: Resurgence’s tired reversion to old formulas and archetypes does little to convince us otherwise. We see disaster after disaster on the nightly news, whether it is caused by war, terrorism or climate change, rendering the film’s scenes of destruction entirely tasteless.

Indeed, the irony of its release on the day of the UK’s disastrous referendum on its membership of the European Union, the result of which has sent the world into economic and political chaos, is difficult to ignore. When Nigel Farage declared June 23 “Independence Day”, he demonstrated ignorance on virtually all levels, not least in cultural terms.

For a whole generation of people, “Independence Day” is roughly equated with visions of apocalypse. Film critic Amy Taubin described the original film as a “feel-good picture about the end of the world”. Independence Day: Resurgence is desperate to capture the optimism of its predecessor, but it is difficult to feel anything other than deeply concerned.

The Conversation

Publication date: 27 June 2016

Home

  • News
    • Latest News
    • News Archive
    • Events
Home

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Bangor University

Bangor, Gwynedd, LL57 2DG, UK

+44 (0)1248 351151

Contact Us

Visit Us

Maps & Directions

Policy

  • Legal Compliance
  • Modern Slavery Act 2015 Statement
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy and Cookies
  • Welsh Language Policy
Map

Bangor University is a Registered Charity: No. 1141565

© 2020 Bangor University