Skip to main content
Home

Information for:

  • Alumni
  • Applicants
  • Current Students
  • Staff
  • Parents
  • Job Vacancies
  • Covid-19
  • Cymraeg
My country:

Main Menu

    • Clearing 2025
      • Clearing Courses
      • Apply Online
      • Call our Clearing Helpline
      • Clearing Live Chat
      • Offer Holder Hub
      • Book Clearing Open Day
    • Accommodation
      • Accommodation Guarantee
      • Find Your Perfect Room
    • About us
      • Virtual Tour
      • Why study in North Wales
      • Our Location
      • Student Clubs and Societies
      • Student Life
      • Reasons to study locally

    Clearing Open Days

    • Undergraduate
      • A–Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • Clearing 2025
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Offer Holders' Hub
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarship and Bursaries
      • Widening Access
      • Study in Welsh
      • Part-Time Study
      • Degree Apprenticeships
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Work Experience
      • Student Accommodation
      • Pocket Prospectus
      • Academic Calendar
    • Postgraduate Taught
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarships and Bursaries
      • Executive Education
      • January Start
      • Part-Time Study
      • Short Courses and CPD
      • A-Z of Short Courses and CPD
    • Postgraduate Research
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Funding
      • The Doctoral School

    Find a Course

    Clearing 2025

    Offer Holders' Hub

    Order a Pocket Prospectus

    Open Days

    Virtual Tour

    • Student Life
      • Student Life Home
      • Bangor and the Area
      • Social Life and Entertainment
      • Student Accommodation
      • Clubs and Societies
      • Sport
      • Virtual Tour
      • Videos and Vlogs
    • Your Experience at Bangor
      • Welcome 2024
      • Student Support
      • Skills and Employability
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Fees and Finances
      • Student Ambassadors

    Student Profiles

    Student Videos and Vlogs

    Welcome Week

    Virtual Tour

    • Choose Bangor
      • International Home
      • Why Bangor?
      • Location
      • Accommodation
      • Student Support
      • Contact Us
      • Bangor University's China website
    • Apply
      • Entry Requirements
      • Tuition Fees and Scholarships
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Study Abroad (Incoming)
      • Exchanges (Incoming)
      • Worldwide Partners

    Clearing 2025

    Country Specific Information

    Bangor University International College

    Find a Course

    • Research
      • Research Home
      • About Our Research
      • Research in our Academic Schools
      • Research Institutes and Centres
      • Research Portal
      • Integrated Research and Impact Support (IRIS) Service
      • Energy
      • REF 2021
      • Research News
    • Postgraduate Research Opportunities
      • Postgraduate Research
      • Doctoral School
    • Events and Training Opportunities
      • Researcher Development

    Royal Recognition: 2023 Queen's Anniversary Prize

    Bangor Research In Top 30 For Societal Impact In UK

    • The University
      • About Us
      • Our Mission
      • Strategy 2030
      • Annual Report & Financial Statements
      • Our Location
      • Academic Schools and Colleges
      • Services and Facilities
      • Vice-Chancellor's Office
      • Working with Business
      • Working with the Community
      • Sustainability
      • Health and Wellbeing
      • Contact Us
    • Working for Us
      • Job Vacancies
    • University Management and Governance
      • Policies and Procedures
      • Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement
      • Management and Governance
    • University and the Community
      • Pontio
      • Sports Facilities
      • Conference Facilities
      • Places to Eat and Drink
      • Public Events
      • Widening Access
      • Services to Schools
    • Business Services
      • Business Services Home
    • Collaboration Hub
      • Collaboration Hub
    • Conferencing and Business Dining
      • Conferencing Facilities
      • Business Dining
    • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
      • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
    • News
      • Current News
      • Research News
      • Student News
    • Events
      • Events
    • Announcements
      • Flag Announcements

    140th Anniversary

    Public Lectures

    • Clearing 2025
      • Clearing Courses
      • Apply Online
      • Book Clearing Open Day
      • Call our Clearing Helpline
      • Clearing Live Chat
      • Offer Holder Hub
    • Accommodation
      • Accommodation Guarantee
      • Find Your Perfect Room
    • About us
      • Virtual Tour
      • Why study in North Wales
      • Our Location
      • Student Clubs and Societies
      • Student Life
      • Reasons to study locally

    Clearing Open Days

    • Undergraduate
      • A–Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • Clearing 2025
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Offer Holders' Hub
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarship and Bursaries
      • Widening Access
      • Study in Welsh
      • Part-Time Study
      • Degree Apprenticeships
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Work Experience
      • Student Accommodation
      • Pocket Prospectus
      • Academic Calendar
    • Postgraduate Taught
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Fees and Finances
      • Scholarships and Bursaries
      • Executive Education
      • January Start
      • Part-Time Study
      • Short Courses and CPD
      • A-Z of Short Courses and CPD
    • Postgraduate Research
      • A-Z of Courses
      • Subject Areas
      • How to Apply
      • Funding
      • The Doctoral School

    Find a Course

    Clearing 2025

    Offer Holders' Hub

    Order a Pocket Prospectus

    Open Days

    Virtual Tour

    • Student Life
      • Student Life Home
      • Bangor and the Area
      • Social Life and Entertainment
      • Student Accommodation
      • Clubs and Societies
      • Sport
      • Virtual Student Experience
      • Videos and Vlogs
    • Your Experience at Bangor
      • Welcome 2024
      • Student Support
      • Skills and Employability
      • Study or Work Abroad
      • Fees and Finances
      • Student Ambassadors

    Student Profiles

    Student Videos and Vlogs

    Welcome Week

    Virtual Tour

    • Choose Bangor
      • International Home
      • Why Bangor?
      • Location
      • Accommodation
      • Student Support
      • Contact Us
      • Bangor University's China website
    • Apply
      • Entry Requirements
      • Tuition Fees and Scholarships
      • How to Apply
      • Already Applied
      • Study Abroad (Incoming)
      • Exchanges (Incoming)
      • Worldwide Partners

    Clearing 2025

    Country Specific Information

    Bangor University International College

    Find a Course

    • Research
      • Research Home
      • About Our Research
      • Research in our Academic Schools
      • Research Institutes and Centres
      • Research Portal
      • Integrated Research and Impact Support (IRIS) Service
      • Energy
      • REF 2021
      • Research News
    • Postgraduate Research Opportunities
      • Postgraduate Research
      • Doctoral School
    • Events and Training Opportunities
      • Researcher Development

    Royal Recognition: 2023 Queen's Anniversary Prize

    Bangor Research In Top 30 For Societal Impact In UK

    • The University
      • About Us
      • Our Mission
      • Strategy 2030
      • Annual Report & Financial Statements
      • Our Location
      • Academic Schools and Colleges
      • Services and Facilities
      • Vice-Chancellor's Office
      • Working with Business
      • Working with the Community
      • Sustainability
      • Health and Wellbeing
      • Contact Us
    • Working for Us
      • Job Vacancies
    • University Management and Governance
      • Policies and Procedures
      • Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement
      • Management and Governance
    • University and the Community
      • Pontio
      • Sports Facilities
      • Conference Facilities
      • Places to Eat and Drink
      • Public Events
      • Widening Access
      • Services to Schools
    • Business Services
      • Business Services Home
    • Collaboration Hub
      • Collaboration Hub
    • Conferencing and Business Dining
      • Conferencing Facilities
      • Business Dining
    • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
      • Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercialisation
    • News
      • Current News
      • Research News
      • Student News
    • Events
      • Events
    • Announcements
      • Flag Announcements

    140th Anniversary

    Public Lectures

Information for:

  • Alumni
  • Applicants
  • Current Students
  • Staff
  • Parents
  • Job Vacancies
  • Covid-19
My country:

Search

Close

Breadcrumb

  • Cymraeg

Share this page:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Getting to the heart of the matter

In recent years the extent of openness, transparency and accountability have become key issues for democracies across the world. In Britain, building on work by the previous administration, the coalition government has stressed the need to 'radically shake-up what transparency means in government'. This includes publishing the death rates of patients operated on by individual cardiac surgeons.

Reporting of hospital and surgeon death rates has been adopted in several countries in recent years, including the US. In Britain they have been published on the internet since 2008.The thinking behind this is that disclosure of such information will lead to improvements in the quality of care, make doctors more accountable, and help patients choose their doctors. However, some frontline doctors have resisted disclosure of mortality rates because it could encourage colleagues to avoid treating clinically difficult patients. Some also claim that death rates obscure other measures of their performance, that the quality of information is poor and that disclosure threatens their freedom to practice.

In a research project for the ESRC Public Services Programme, co-funded by the General Medical Council (the regulatory body for doctors), Dr Mark Exworthy and Professor Jonathan Gabe from Royal Holloway-University of London, and Ian Rees Jones from Bangor University, explored the impact of disclosure of death rates on cardiac surgeons. In 2009, they undertook an in-depth study at the micro level of a surgical unit, the meso level of the hospital in which the unit was based and the local Primary Care Trust, and the macro level of the regulatory environment. The research explored the connections between clinical professionals, managers and regulators.

At the micro level, the researchers found differences of opinion among the surgeons about the consequences of disclosing their individual death rates. While trainee surgeons accepted the reporting of death rates, there was some resistance from senior surgeons who saw it as a threat to their autonomy. All surgeons recognised that disclosure was changing trainees' experiences and reducing opportunities to operate on high-risk patients. And as published death rates for named surgeons also include juniors working under their supervision, such surgeons were more likely to operate on high-risk patients themselves so as to avoid a negative impact of the published death rate.

At the meso level, hospital managers did not use the information about death rates to manage surgeons. They approached these issues cautiously, working with local clinical leaders. However, they could see the benefit of publishing low mortality rates to attract patients. Primary Care Trusts were not using this information when they commissioned acute medical services.

At the macro level, policymakers and professional bodies were enthusiastic about publishing death rates; the Care Quality Commission (regulator) and Society for Cardio-thoracic Surgeons (surgeons’ professional body) have co-sponsored a heart surgery website to report surgeons' death rates. Given the lack of enthusiasm from some senior surgeons, divisions may become apparent in the future between the surgical leaders and rank-and-file surgeons.

It is significant that research from the US and Britain suggests that patients do not use reported death rates to inform their decisions. Death rates for British cardiac surgery are currently below two percent of operations, suggesting that most patients survive surgery. Hence, work is now directed towards other measures such as quality of life, which are reported by patients. Equally, as reporting remains voluntary, a quarter of surgeons do not release their death rates for publication. Little is known about this group who do not disclose.

Reporting the performance of public services is likely to accelerate and broaden in scope. But while reporting brings important benefits, it is not a magic bullet for the problems of health services.

From the ESRC magazine Britain in 2011

Publication date: 4 March 2011

Home

  • News
    • Latest News
    • News Archive
    • Events
Home

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Bangor University

Bangor, Gwynedd, LL57 2DG, UK

+44 (0)1248 351151

Contact Us

Visit Us

Maps & Directions

Policy

  • Legal Compliance
  • Modern Slavery Act 2015 Statement
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy and Cookies
  • Welsh Language Policy
Map

Bangor University is a Registered Charity: No. 1141565

© 2020 Bangor University