Modiwl HTH-2124:
Heritage and Identity

Ffeithiau’r Modiwl

Rhedir gan School of History, Philosophy and Social Sciences

20 Credyd neu 10 Credyd ECTS

Semester 2

Trefnydd: Prof Raimund Karl

Amcanion cyffredinol

The past - both its material remains and our cherished myths - is increasingly being commodified as 'heritage'. As such, material land immaterial culture is constantly being used both as a resource to sustain a modern industry and also to underpin the social, cultural and political identities of individuals, groups, regions, places, nation states, and globally. Heritage can often be associated with minority groups and dominant elites and this unit will examine the various arenas through which these identities are communicated, ranging from museums and the practice of archaeology, to oral culture and memory. We will therefore trespass quite freely over traditional disciplinary boundaries and discuss topics relevant to history, archaeology, political science and sociology. However, you need to keep in mind the main theme of the course: what is the role of material and immaterial culture in the construction of identity? With this aim in mind, we will examine the role of heritage in the shaping of a whole range of individual and group identities, both in contemporary society and historically. We will begin with looking at how humans, in general, use the past, both their own individual life history and culturally transmitted accounts of the communal history, to create their own realities and identities. Following this, we will look at various sorts of identities and how heritage is used - or misused - in their creation, looking at a wide range of case studies covering topics like national identities, racism and identity, religious identity, linguistic identity, professional group identities, local identities, minority and elite group identities, the globalisation of 'western' identity, and will pay a visit to the supermarket of individual identity creation, as well as having a look at how heritage was used to create identities in the past. Although heritage is usually a benign force, we shall focus on the idea of 'contested' or 'dissonant' heritage, where the legacy of the past has been used, intentionally or accidentally, as a source of social or political conflict and division

Cynnwys cwrs

Individual, group, local, regional, national and global identities; museums; political and cultural role of archaeology and history, the heritage in minority groups, the heritage of elites, oral culture, heritage and the nation state, the creation of heritage-based identities in past societies.

Meini Prawf

ardderchog

Excellent students (A- and above) will show strong achievement across all the criteria combined with particularly impressive depths of knowledge and/or subtlety of analysis. In written work, they will support their arguments with a wealth of relevant detail/examples. They will also demonstrate an acute awareness of the relevant historiography and give an account of why the conclusions reached are important within a particular historical debate. They may show a particularly subtle approach to possible objections, nuancing their argument in the light of counter-examples, or producing an interesting synthesis of various contrasting positions. Overall, the standards of content, argument, and analysis expected will be consistently superior to top upper-second work. Standards of presentation will also be high.

trothwy

Threshold students (D- and D) will have done only a minimum of reading, and their work will often be based partly on lecture notes and/or basic textbooks. They will demonstrate in their written assessments some knowledge of at least parts of the relevant field, and will make at least partially-successful attempts to frame an argument which engages with historical controversies, but they will fail to discuss some large and vital aspects of a topic; and/or deploy only some relevant material but partly fail to combine it into a coherent whole; and/or deploy some evidence to support individual points but often fail to do so and/or show difficulty weighing evidence (thereby relying on unsuitable or irrelevant evidence when making a point). Alternatively or additionally, the presentation of the work might also be poor, with bad grammar and/or punctuation, careless typos and spelling errors, and a lack of effective and correct referencing.

C- i C+

Students in this band (C- to C+) will demonstrate a satisfactory range of achievement or depth of knowledge of most parts of the module, and will make successful, if occasionally inconsistent, attempts to develop those skills appropriate to the study of History at undergraduate level. In the case of the written assessments, the answers will attempt to focus on the question, although might drift into narrative, and will show some evidence of solid reading and research. The argument might lose direction and might not be adequately clear at the bottom of this category. Written work will be presented reasonably well with only limited errors in grammar, punctuation, and referencing, and not to the extent that they obscure meaning.

da

Good students (B- to B+) will demonstrate a solid level of achievement and depth of knowledge in all the criteria in the C- to C+ range, and will in addition exhibit constructive engagement with different types of historical writing and historiographical interpretation. Ideas will be communicated effectively and written work will include a good range of sources/reading and demonstrate a clear understanding of the issues and of the existing interpretations expressed in a well-structured, relevant, and focused argument. Students at the top end of this band will engage with and critique the ideas that they come across, and synthesise the various interpretations they find to reach their own considered conclusions. Written work will be correctly presented with references and bibliography where appropriate.

Canlyniad dysgu

  1. An ability to present clear, cogent and evidence-based arguments about aspects of the role of heritage in the construction of identity in two essays, and support these with evidence.

  2. Show a detailed awareness of the varying contributions made by heritage to different forms of identity and an ability to compare and contrast the role of heritage in the creation of of different forms of identity

  3. Demonstrate an in-depth knowledge of the role of heritage in creating various froms of individual and group identity.

  4. An ability to analyse documentary evidence or a particular heritage site and discuss its relevance to wider issues within heritage studies.

Dulliau asesu

Math Enw Disgrifiad Pwysau
TRAETHAWD Essay 1 (c. 3500 words)

c. 3,000 word essay. Choose one of the following topics: 1) Discuss the role of material evidence in the construction of individual and group identities. 2) Discuss the role of textual evidence in the construction of religious identity. 3) Discuss the role of past oppression in the construction of minority group identity. 4) Discuss the role of heritage in the construction of ethnic identity. 5) Discuss the role of language and/or music and/or literature in the construction of group identities. 7) Discuss the role of collecting in the creation of elite group identities. 8) Discuss the effects of globalisation on local identity construction. 9) Discuss the role of mythical history in the construction of identity in the Middle Ages. 10) Discuss the relationship between archaeology and nationalism. 11) Discuss the influence of heritage in the construction of a German super-race. 12) Discuss the role of heritage in the creation of the professional identity of heritage professionals. 14) Discuss the uses of the same heritage in the construction of different or opposing group identities.

50
TRAETHAWD Essay 2 (c. 3500 words)

c. 3,000 word essay. Chose a topic (other than the one you already chose for your first essay) from the following list: 1) Discuss the role of material evidence in the construction of individual and group identities. 2) Discuss the role of textual evidence in the construction of religious identity. 3) Discuss the role of past oppression in the construction of minority group identity. 4) Discuss the role of heritage in the construction of ethnic identity. 5) Discuss the role of language and/or music and/or literature in the construction of group identities. 7) Discuss the role of collecting in the creation of elite group identities. 8) Discuss the effects of globalisation on local identity construction. 9) Discuss the role of mythical history in the construction of identity in the Middle Ages. 10) Discuss the relationship between archaeology and nationalism. 11) Discuss the influence of heritage in the construction of a German super-race. 12) Discuss the role of heritage in the creation of the professional identity of heritage professionals. 14) Discuss the uses of the same heritage in the construction of different or opposing group identities.

50

Strategaeth addysgu a dysgu

Oriau
External visit

Field trip to a relevant heritage site or sites.

10
Seminar 9
Private study 170
Lecture 11

Sgiliau Trosglwyddadwy

  • Llythrennedd - Medrusrwydd mewn darllen ac ysgrifennu drwy amrywiaeth o gyfryngau
  • Rhifedd - Medrusrwydd wrth ddefnyddio rhifau ar lefelau priodol o gywirdeb
  • Defnyddio cyfrifiaduron - Medrusrwydd wrth ddefnyddio ystod o feddalwedd cyfrifiadurol
  • Hunanreolaeth - Gallu gweithio mewn ffordd effeithlon, prydlon a threfnus. Gallu edrych ar ganlyniadau tasgau a digwyddiadau, a barnu lefelau o ansawdd a phwysigrwydd
  • Archwilio - Gallu ymchwilio ac ystyried dewisiadau eraill
  • Adalw gwybodaeth - Gallu mynd at wahanol ac amrywiol ffynonellau gwybodaeth
  • Sgiliau Rhyngbersonol - Gallu gofyn cwestiynau, gwrando'n astud ar atebion a'u harchwilio
  • Dadansoddi Beirniadol & Datrys Problem - Gallu dadelfennu a dadansoddi problemau neu sefyllfaoedd cymhleth. Gallu canfod atebion i broblemau drwy ddadansoddiadau ac archwilio posibiliadau
  • Ymwybyddiaeth o ddiogelwch - Bod yn ymwybodol o'ch amgylchedd a hyder o ran cadw at reoliadau iechyd a diogelwch
  • Cyflwyniad - Gallu cyflwyno gwybodaeth ac esboniadau yn glir i gynulleidfa. Trwy gyfryngau ysgrifenedig neu ar lafar yn glir a hyderus.
  • Gwaith Tîm - Gallu cydweithio'n adeiladol ag eraill ar dasg gyffredin, ac/neu fod yn rhan o dîm gweithio o ddydd i ddydd
  • Dadl - Gallu cyflwyno, trafod a chyfiawnhau barn neu lwybr gweithredu, naill ai gydag unigolyn neu mewn grwˆp ehangach
  • Hunanymwybyddiaeth & Ystyried - Bod yn ymwybodol o'ch cryfderau, gwendidau, nodau ac amcanion eich hun. Gallu adolygu ,cloriannu a myfyrio'n rheolaidd ar eich perfformiad eich hun ac eraill.

Sgiliau pwnc penodol

  • problem solving to develop solutions to understand the past
  • understanding the complexity of change over time; in specific contexts and chronologies
  • being sensitive to the differences, or the "otherness" of the past, and the difficulty to using it as a guide to present or future action
  • being sensitive to the role of perceptions of the past in contemporary cultures
  • producing logical and structured arguments supported by relevant evidence
  • planning, designing, executing and documenting a programme of research, working independently
  • marshalling and critically appraising other people's arguments, including listening and questioning
  • presenting effective oral presentations for different kinds of audiences, including academic and/or audiences with little knowledge of history
  • preparing effective written communications for different readerships
  • making effective and appropriate forms of visual presentation
  • making effective and appropriate use of relevant information technology
  • making critical and effective use of information retrieval skills using paper-based and electronic resources
  • collaborating effectively in a team via experience of working in a group
  • appreciating and being sensitive to different cultures and dealing with unfamiliar situations
  • critical evaluation of one's own and others' opinions
  • engaging with relevant aspects of current agendas such as global perspectives, public engagement, employability, enterprise, and creativity

Adnoddau

Goblygiadau o ran adnoddau ar gyfer myfyrwyr

Entrance fee for site or sites visited on field trip (usually c. £ 10)

Rhestr ddarllen

Introductory bibliography P. Bourdieu, Outline of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge Studies in Social Anthropology 16. (1977) M. Diaz-Andreu and T. Champion (eds.), Nationalism and Archaeology in Europe. (1996) J.M. Fladmark (ed.), Heritage and Museums: Shaping National Identities. (2000) J.M. Fladmark (ed.), Heritage and Identity. Papers presented at the 2001 Heritage Convention. (2002) L.C. Garro, ‘The remembered past in a culturally meaningful life: remembering as cultural, social, and cognitive process’. In: C.C. Moore and H.F. Mathews (eds.), The psychology of Cultural Experience. (2001): 105-50 J.R. Gillis (ed.), Commemorations: The Politics of National Identity. (1994) B. Graham, G.J. Ashworth and J.E. Tunbridge, A Geography of Heritage. (2000) B. Graham & P. Howard (eds.) The Ashgate Research Companion to Heritage and Identity (2008) P. Graves-Brown, S. Jones and C. Gamble (eds.), Cultural Identity and Archaeology. The Construction of European Communities. (1996) H. Härke (ed.), Archaeology, Ideology and Society: The German Experience. (2000) D.C. Harvey, ‘Heritage Pasts and Heritage Presents: temporality, meaning and the scope of heritage studies’, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 7:4 (2001), 319-338 D.T. Herbert (ed.), Heritage, Tourism and Society. (1997) S. James, The Atlantic Celts. Ancient People or Modern Invention? (1999) S. Jones, The Archaeology of Ethnicity. (1997) R.A. Levine and K. Norman, ‘The infant’s acquisition of culture: early attachment reexamined in an anthropological perspective’. In: C.C. Moore and H.F. Mathews (eds.), The psychology of Cultural Experience. (2001): 83-104. D. Lowenthal, The Past is a Foreign Country. (1985) D. Lowenthal, The Heritage Crusade and the Spoils of History. (1996) D. Lowenthal, Natural and cultural heritage, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 11:1 (2005), 81-92 McLean, F., Introduction: Heritage and Identity, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 12:1, (2006) 3-7 Merriman,N. 2004. Public Archaeology, Oxon: Routledge K.R. McCone, Pagan Past and Christian Present in Early Irish Literature. Maynooth Monographs No. 3 (1990) B. W. Porter & N.B. Salazar, Heritage Tourism, conflict, and the public interest: an introduction, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 11:5 (2005), 361-70 S.J. Shennan (ed.), Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity. (1989) N.A. Silberman, ‘If I forget thee, O Jerusalem: Archaeology, Religious Commemoration and Nationalism in a Disputed City, 1801-2001’. Nations and Nationalism 7 (2001): 487-504. E. von Glasersfeld, Radical Constructivism. A way of knowing and learning, (1995) Waterton, E. & L. Smith, The recognition and misrecognition of community heritage, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 16 Nos. 1-2 (2010), 4-15

Cyrsiau sy’n cynnwys y modiwl hwn

Gorfodol mewn cyrsiau:

Opsiynol mewn cyrsiau: